Blog 11 – Intertextual Elements

March 18, 2009

A similarity I found that is shared between Ragtime and In The Lake Of The Woods is how strong of an effect the need for acceptance and love can have on a person. In O’Brien’s story, John Wade became obsessed with the need to be loved. “Sometimes he did bad things just to be loved, and sometimes he hated himself for needing love so badly” (O’Brien 60). These ‘bad things’ that O’Brien writes includes extreme actions such as following (or as Wade coined it, spying) his wife, even before they were married. And because of his quenchless need to always feel loved, Wade was filled with terror at the thought of ever losing Kathy. It’s seems as though it is driving him to the point of insanity.

Parallel to Wade’s obsession is Younger Brother’s strange behaviors in Ragtime. Younger Brother was entirely consumed by thoughts of a woman, but in his case Evelyn Nesbit. He, too, followed her around while she remained completely unaware. Younger Brother’s stalker-ish behavior continued to spiral out of control until finally he was caught. “At this moment a hoarse unearthly cry issued from the walls, the closet door flew open and Mother’s Younger Brother fell into the room, his face twisted in a paroxysm of saintly mortification” (Doctorow 63).

In both cases, despite their strange and disapproving actions, both John Wade and Younger Brother get the women they obsess over. However, Younger Brother eventually  looses Evelyn Nesbit to her own flightiness and it appears John Wade looses Kathy, even though how he lost her is yet to be determined. I find the series of events – stalking/spying, winning the girl, losing the girl – demonstrated in both stories to be an interesting intertextual element between Ragtime and In The Lake Of The Woods.

4 Responses to “Blog 11 – Intertextual Elements”

  1. vmd2012 Says:

    I also wrote on this topic and I feel that the women chose to start/continue their relationships with the men because they both craved the attention of their respected lovers.

  2. stephenenglish112 Says:

    This example of intertextuality that you point out here is definitely a great example between the two novels. Both Mother’s Younger Brother and John show this insane lust that is only quenched by their spying and stalking. Good pick up. I like your usage of “quenchless”.

  3. sutheraj Says:

    I think this is a really good parallel between the two books. Something you could look more into is how each book/character’s response portrays loss and what it means.

  4. flygirl12 Says:

    Great display of comprehension of the dialogue and the similarities between the characters. Use of quotes builds your argument

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s